Best Defender Bytes:

January 14, 2011

Ninth Circuit Opinions 01-12-2011

Filed under: California Appeals Attorney — Tags: , , , — fayarfa @ 4:27 am

First degree murder convictions affirmed for sufficient evidence of premeditation.

US v. Begay, No. 07-10487 )(en banc majority opinion by Clifton; dissent by Reinhardt, Thomas and Berzon).

[Ed. note:  This case came from the FPD Arizona office]  The defendant was convicted of two counts of first degree murder and two gun counts.  The panel had vacated the first degree murder convictions for insufficient evidence of premeditation and had affirmed the gun counts.

Taking the case en banc, the 9th now reverses the panel, and affirms the first degree murder convictions as having sufficient evidence.  The facts involve the defendant shooting two individuals after they had stopped their cars early in the morning of March 28, 2002.  The prosecution argued sufficient evidence for premeditation through the acts of the defendant turning around from an initial conversation, walking to his car, getting a rifle and then shooting.

There was no evidence of agitation or being rushed.  Using the Nevils two prong test for sufficiency, see 598 F.3d at 1164, the acts have to be viewed in the light most favorable to the gov’t, and whether such facts adequately support the decision by any rational jury.  The majority found that the facts here did.  The dissent argued that the decision to go en banc was flawed because it wasn’t to address national importance, circuit conflict or intra-circuit conflict, but to reconsider a few specific case-bound facts.

The panel found that the gov’t failed to prove premeditation and so the murder was second as opposed to first degree.  The conclusion is that en banc was to reconsider the interpretation of these facts, which is improper.  The dissent argues that the gov’t never proved premeditation but only intent.  Premeditation is specific intent.  The gov’t did not present any of the evidence usually presented for premeditation, such as motive, demeanor, prior relationship, or whether the means was calculated.  The record is silent on such facts. There is no support for premeditation.


  1. I am wanting to own a lovely double adjustable piano bench. I am so glad that this article is incredibly insightful.

    Comment by test website — March 17, 2013 @ 8:27 am

  2. Board and Care Home by DOVERWOOD ASSISTED LIVING…

    Loving Home with kind care givers. DOVERWOOD ASSISTED LIVING is a awesome place for your family member…

    Trackback by DOVERWOOD ASSISTED LIVING — April 11, 2013 @ 4:36 pm

  3. At times like this it boils down to finding the information required, which as I’m sure you know can take some time. This post helped me figure out what I needed.

    Comment by Investment Rarities — November 16, 2015 @ 3:10 pm

  4. Be sure to preserve your life force, chi. This practice is absolutely essential. Be sure to respect the power of words. Don’t engage in vulgar language or activity.

    Comment by driptite — November 23, 2015 @ 2:03 am

  5. One thing they did say about her though was that she loved olive oil, which is why she lived so long. Impressive when you sit down and think of it.

    Comment by — November 24, 2015 @ 10:56 pm

  6. I couldn’t agree more! This is something I have often thought about and I’m glad that you brought it to my attention.

    Comment by Richard rafes — December 3, 2015 @ 6:41 pm

  7. Life can be tough at times, you put in the hours of work and only end up with blank stares. You know what I mean? That’s the time posts like this keep me motivated.

    Comment by Management Success — December 28, 2015 @ 3:32 am

  8. Our proficient team comprising of highly skilled web designers aim to deliver performance oriented services. They strive to build and develop brilliant websites that helps customers to build their brand online in the most effective and efficient way.

    Comment by neil camenker — December 28, 2015 @ 3:41 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress